| (8) Elim Gospel | 5 | | |
| (1) Rush Methodist | 24 | | |
| Tue 7/17/2012 | Semmel Road - 5 innings (mercy) - | (4) Avon Wesleyan | 7 | |
| | (1) Rush Methodist | 15 | |
| (5) Twins | 11 | Tue 7/24/2012 | Semmel Road - | |
| (4) Avon Wesleyan | 16 | | |
| Tue 7/17/2012 | Lima Baptist - | | (3) Grace Life | 3 |
| | | (1) Rush Methodist | 6 |
| (7) Good Shepherd | 6 | | Tue 8/14/2012 | Semmel Road - |
| (2) New Hope Fellowship | 21 | | |
| Tue 7/17/2012 | Bloomfield Central - 6 innings (mercy) - | (3) Grace Life | 13 | |
| | (2) New Hope Fellowship | 12 | |
| (6) Honeoye Falls Methodist | 7 | Tue 7/24/2012 | Bloomfield Central - | |
| (3) Grace Life | 22 | | |
| Tue 7/17/2012 | Elim Gospel - 5 innings (mercy) - | | |
